“One Sweet Cookie” Cheesecake Brownies – Rich Winter Dessert

I recently tried what I think will be my final "One Sweet Cookie" recipe – the Cheesecake Brownies by Nicole Kaplan of the Institute of Culinary Education.  The brownies took several hours to make – one has to first make the brownie/chocolate layer and then freeze the batter for several hours before adding the cheesecake layer.  The recipe was otherwise fairly simple and easy to follow, though unlike the recipe directions, the cheesecake layer did not set after 40 minutes of baking, nor 55 minutes of baking.  After some frantic googling, I decided to not risk overbaking the brownies and instead took them out of the oven at approximately 55 minutes of baking.  Only 1 inch around the edges were fully set, but I followed the counsel of internet posts that stated that the brownies were firm up after cooling and being placed in the fridge or freezer.  

Sadly, the brownies never really firmed up, but the result was still very tasty, albeit very rich.  The chocolate layer was very dense and fudgy, and the cheesecake layer was a pretty intense sweet cheese flavor as well.  

One Sweet Cookie Cheesecake Brownies

I brought the brownies to a dinner get-together, and they were a hit.  I think this is a great recipe to re-try during cold weather months, though I may end up reducing the cream cheese from 1.5 pounds to 1 or 0.75 pounds to make a more manageable dessert experience (and reduce the required cooking time).  I might also try a different brownie base that is slightly less fudgy and more cake-like in consistency.  In any case, I'll keep in my mind that folks really seemed to like this dessert in its original form – including Noah, who kept asking for more!


Noah Eating Cheesecake Brownies

Comments

One response to ““One Sweet Cookie” Cheesecake Brownies – Rich Winter Dessert”

  1. Kristen Avatar
    Kristen

    Thanks for posting, glad to no I’m not alone! I also tried this very same recipe from the “One Sweet Cookie” book today intending to bring to Thanksgiving. My layer did not set up either after 40 minutes, in fact it was about the consistency of yogurt at the forty minute mark. I continued to cook them ten minutes at a time (checking the doneness every ten minutes or so). I ended up cooking them a total of 70-80 minutes which basically doubled the cook time and pulled them out once the top of the cheesecake was starting to brown (fearing that now the brownie underneath was probably overcooked). The cheesecake even though slightly brown was still not set up and when I cut a tiny square from one of the corners to sample it, the brownie batter was just that, still batter. So now I am continuing to bake them at 325 degrees, put tinfoil on top (to protect the cheesecake layer from browning any further) and am currently baking for 20 more minutes. My guess is that the pan size was supposed to be written as a 9″ x 13″ and not a 9″ square. That would also make sense given that the recipe is supposed to yield 36 small brownies. I don’t see cutting 36 brownies from a 9″ square baking pan. By the way, I just checked on my brownies and the extra 20 minutes with tinfoil did the trick. Now I’m going to get them in the freezer to stop the cooking process as to not overcook the brownies (they continue to bake from being left in the hot pan). Hope this helps!
    -Kristen

Leave a Reply to KristenCancel reply

Discover more from Madhu Knits and Cooks

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading