I recently made the Cook's Illustrated Thick and Chewy Gingerbread Cookie recipe and while assembling the ingredients, I realized that I did not have the exact measurements the recipe called for. Unfortunately, many people I know would have told me to stop there. I have been told time and time again that "baking is chemisty" and that to get a good baked good result, one needs to follow a recipe EXACTLY. I really dislike having those conversations because I don't think that baking is or needs to be more precise than cooking. I make modifications frequently to baked goods, and although the result may not be perfect (just like most of my cooking isn't perfect), nothing is actually perfect to everyone. We all have different palates and making baking modifications, like making cooking modifications, isn't wrong to achieve the outcomes we want. I don't mean substitute baking powder for baking soda (there is certainly chemistry in baking), but I think people should treat baking like cooking – experimenting to find something you like, and using the recipe as a guide and not a fail-safe scientific formula.
So, in any case, modifications I made. I only had around 1/2 a cup of molasses (probably btwn. 1/3 and 1/2 cup of molasses), so I just used that. I added more liquid in the form of adding maybe 3.5 tbsps. of low-fat milk. The dark sugar I used was also a bit dry and old, so I warmed it up in the microwave with some water to make it more moist. I reduced the baking time to about 7 – 8 minutes to avoid too dry cookies and to adjust for making much smaller cookies – in the form of Star Wars cutouts.
The result was great – soft, chewy and thin cookies, which were rich in flavor. I look forward to making more in the coming winter months!
